This post is a compilation of smart things my AI says. They could be abt me, or the world, or the upcoming elections. :)
****
Your face is apparently incapable of signing an NDA with your thoughts.
This is a random personal blog - covering everything from poetry to politics. Views presented are strictly my own.
This post is a compilation of smart things my AI says. They could be abt me, or the world, or the upcoming elections. :)
****
Your face is apparently incapable of signing an NDA with your thoughts.
Dear Airlines:
We do NOT want a round trip fare because if we miss the first leg, you treat the whole booking as no-show. So, please don't default to "Round Trip" when we are looking for a trip. We are old and irritated. We will just postpone the decision to book.
Dear Quick Commerce:
Dark Patterns are passe. We are basically incompetent. If we could get up and go to the grocery store, we would. Convenience is our golden pass. So just overcharge as much as you want, so long as you do it in 2 clicks or less.
Dear Gmail:
The Home page on Edge requires me to click on "Sign in" once again before actually signing in (why do u think i came to gmail.com? To admire the layout?) while on Brave it does directly to the username screen.
Can you PLEASE go back to the times when we put the id and the password and did ONE click?
Those microseconds are costing many hours of person time.
You go in with expectations. You go in expecting to be entertained. Your mind has already told you that you are going to love this film because you have made the effort to get out of the house, drive to a theater, and sit in a mildly comfortable seat - for 3 hours. In this day and age, that is a massive commitment of time and attention. So, your mind is preconditioned to love the film.
Then, the film begins.
The only technical aspect that works well is the sound. That is well balanced.
This is just the technical team.
Now to the storytelling and what is called "creative"
If the director had a vision, it is not coming through.
If story telling was intended, that has not happened.
Casting, though a tech feature, is being mentioned here because so much of a story depends on the actors telling it. Ranvir is usually a very expressive actor. But in this film, the director has completely muted his performance. Not ONE scene gives you goosebumps. Not the death of Dashrath, not Bharat milaap, not even the vanvaas. Even the neighbourhood Ramleela does it better.
The rest of the cast is either poorly chosen or poorly directed because not ONCE does an actor portray through their eyes and face. At many places, it looks like AI is playing the character bcs the real actor would do things differently.
Ravana is being praised in many reviews but his character is basically unidimensional. As is everyone else's. The dialogues are SO BAD. The delivery is flatter than still water in a glass. There isn't ONE memorable dialogue or song that leaves the theater with you.
Some of the events have been reimagined. Ram's search for "Why was i born?" is refreshing. It may not work for everyone, but it worked for me. However, "Only this vanvas will tell me what destiny really has in store for me" is kind of... flat. Doesn't come through.
Ram making the ekpatnivrat to his fil at his wedding also makes no sense.
Everyone has already mentioned that the first half crawls and the second half at least manages to walk. Even for me, the second half was better paced than the first.
That's it. That's the review.
It takes serious effort to take a story as beautiful, nuanced, and layered as Ramayana, to have the power of money, CGI, and AI, and then to get basics like tech, dialogues, and casting wrong. Amazing!!
Monday Blues
Posts like this:
I am writing them here instead of a dedicated C PTSD support group because my own diagnosis came almost accidently but has been a totally pathbreaking thing for me.
Sometimes, we dont know what's happening and why. Just in case anyone comes this way and finds some recognition, and it helps them, that would be nice.
Here is how C PTSD operated for me yesterday. Mom arrived to spend a few days here. How does the nervous system react? Palpitations and insomnia. I have ZERO control over this. I have NO IDEA why this is happening (patterns and all, sure, but that explanation is not helpful). WHY is my system bracing for a terror impact? There is no terror. I am safe. But the system does not know that. It keeps me up the whole night, too ? to fall asleep.
I usually take a few days to settle down with anyone from the family. That is to be expected. Now, instead of blaming myself for being the runaway child who is no good, I give self the time and space to adjust. Allow myself to be a little prickly. Allow myself to experience both gratitude for having a living parent AND the sharp urge to run away from any personal question about health or life. In a couple of days, we will find activities that we can do together without being emotionally impacted.
हर रिश्ते की बुनियाद भी होती है, और मियाद भी होती है।
पर इन दोनों का आपस में रिश्ता हो, ये ज़रूरी नहीं।
गहरी बुनियाद से मियाद हमेशा लंबी नहीं होती
लंबी मियाद में भी बुनियाद कभी अछूती रह जाती है।
हल्की बुनियाद पर लंबी मियाद की दोस्तियां तो क्या, शादियाँ भी निभ जाती हैं
और गहरी बुनियाद पर बने रिश्ते छोटी मियाद ले कर आते हैं, जैसे दिवाली के अनार।
पुस्तक मेले से ढूंढ धाँध कर लाई किताब का अपना दंभ होता है। कोई नाम नहीं, कोई समीक्षा नहीं। मन ने शब्दों को चुना होता है।
घर आ कर जब ये शब्द पढ़ कर मन से वाह! निकलती है, तो वह कुछ कुछ ऐसी होती है जैसे मन पसंद चाय की चुस्की!
कविता की किताब अपनी बात खुद कह सकती है। उसे कहने देते हैं ...
खुद ही प्यासे हैं समंदर तो फकत नाम के हैं
भूल जाओ कि बड़े लोग किसी काम के हैं
दस्तकें खास उसी वक़्त में देता है कोई
चार-छ: पल जो मेरी उम्र में आराम के हैं
**********
वो संग दिल जो अभी रो पड़ा तो इल्म हुआ
कि उस पहाड़ के सीने में एक झरना है
*****
अचानक रुक गई तो देखती हूँ
मेरे चलने से रिश्ता चल रहा था
********
मैं जागती हूँ मुझे काम कुछ नहीं आखिर
वो सो गया है उसे काम पर निकलना था
*****
ज़िंदगी भर जमीन का खाया
मरने तक आसमान को सोचा
*****
हमें नसीब मिला है किसी जज़ीरे का
खुशी के बीच में रह कर उदास रहना है
*********
तुम्हारी धमकियों पर जां सदके
दिले बर्बाद को अब क्या ही खतरा
********
ईमान ले कर आई हूँ बाजार में जरूर
पर बेचना नहीं है मुझे देखना है भाव
*******
थोड़ी सी दिल में क्या जगह मांगी
वो मुहाजिर समझ रहे हैं मुझे
***********
हम अंधेरे में रहने वाले लोग
गिनते रहते हैं गिनती 100 तक की
***
ख्वाब सब मेरे मुकम्मल हो गए
नींद भी तेरे बिना आने लगी
****
मेरी उदास मिजाज़ी पे मत तरस खाओ
मैं वो ग़ज़ल हूँ जिसे सब की दाद हासिल है
********
Maybe it is the unfinished that goads us more than the finished.
NCIS is a good crime show. I like police procedurals bcs they follow the path of predictability. In NCIS, forensics, footwork, and psychology come together to create a cogent narrative in each case.
BUT, it is Tony and Ziva - the unfinished business, that really haunts.
So, after Tony redeemed himself in S7 E 1, one expected them to move to a reln shortly after.
BUT they don't. Not for a long time.
The authors have their logic, of course, but we don't.
I told a colleague about being frustrated with this aspect of the show being really unrealistic. The rest of the show has a plausible storyline. But Tony and Ziva is just off the whack.
She challenged me to write my own story. And i did. Then I did what any fledgeling author does - showed it to AI and asked it to give suggestions. Thats when i realised that there is an entire fanfic body of work that addresses the same plothole that was bugging me!
But first, here's mine. It takes place S8, before the Eli David coming to Washington episode:
Setting: Late night at the NCIS office. Everyone else has gone home and Tony and Ziva are the only ones, packing up.
Ziva is wearing a white blouse with blue trousers. The blouse is knotted in the front. She pairs it with a gold links necklace. Diamond stud earrings. Hair loose, falling to the right of her face.
Tony is wearing a pale blue monochrome cotton/linen shirt with dark blue trouers and a classy belt. No jacket, but in the background we can see his jacket on the chair back of his desk. HIs belt is a Dolce with just a hint of gold glint. This gold glint is later used with lighting to just produce a little bit of mystique about him. The brand does not scream, but it contributes to the rest of the story.
Tony: Should we start over?
Ziva: Start over what?
Tony: The story.
Ziva(understanding and a little confused, just looks at him)
Tony walks towards her, stands right by her desk but does not lean in: That story in which we start off on the wrong foot. I tease you, you hate me.
Ziva (sharply): I don't hate you!!
Tony: No you just love McGee more.
Ziva, smiles, shakes her head, and looks down.
There is a pause. Tony is looking straight at her, but not saying anything. Ziva is looking down, then looking to her right as she does.
Tony: Spit it.
Ziva: Spit what?
Tony: Why you won't see what's in plain sight.
Ziva: And now you are going to say something irritating.
Tony: Nope! Not this time. This time, I will wait. Until we talk. Until YOU talk.
Ziva: I gotta go.
Tony: Not tonight, you don't. Tonight, wherever you go, we go together. Until
Ziva: Until what?
Gibbs (passing by): Until you finish the talk i told u to do, Giva. (pauses next to Tony. Looks straight at Ziva and then at Tony. Does NOT do the Gibbs nod. He does do the Gibbs understanding eyes smile. Then he leaves)
Ziva looks visibly restless but Tony is looking at her in that same way like Sahara desert. Straight. Unblinking.
Ziva: What do you want me to say?
Tony: Take a Truth serum, Ziva, and tell me (pauses, moves to face her, then starts to circle her really close, moving to the right first. Ziva's eyes follow him, but they are placed at the belt level. Tony's eyes are on Ziva throughout). He moves to her right, crosses her without touching her, but then stands, exactly side by side, looking at her unflinching. But not saying anything. When Tony stops, Ziva looks up at him:
Ziva: Tell you what?
Tony : You do not see me as a man capable of passion. You see me as the town clown. As the crackpot who cracks jokes at everything and everyone. Who is never serious. Who does not, cannot, love...
Ziva: (looks away, to her left, facing away from Tony): But you CAN love. I have seen it. (RTC: Tony's love for Jeanne Benoit, S4)
Tony: Oho! So thats why!
Ziva: No. That's not why.
Tony: Then why?
Ziva: Its not you, Tony. Its me. I cannot be trusted.
Tony (appears surprised for just a second. Then turns 180 degrees, takes her hand, and sighs): THIS is going to be a long night.
Ziva (first appears concerned, then that look of having figured something out, and then she says nothing, but starts walking with Tony towards the lift. Her face is inscrutable. There is that cover of determination and nonchalance, but her eyes look troubled and unsure. Closest scene parallel, after she has just killed Ari and walks down the stairs, where we see her face for the first time)
Background music starts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s11K70Xs1cE&list=RDs11K70Xs1cE&start_radio=1 (3rd Movement (Andante) from Bach's Sonata No. 2 in A minor, BWV 1003).
They find Abby stepping out of the lift. Abby is dressed in white in a tennis dress silhouette, with black piping on the sides to accentuate her figure.
She looks from Tony to Ziva, then at their hands, and then, she takes a step towards Tony, stares at him straight, then turns to Ziva and asks "Is that...?"
Tony and Ziva leave hands immediately and Ziva snaps "Absolutely not!"
Abby is stunned by Ziva's snapping and hugs her.
While hugging her, Abby says: The demons are outside, and they are big. Their shadows are inside us, and sometimes, the shadows are bigger than the demons. But here's the fun part - If you walk towards your light, the shadows have no choice but to fall behind you.
Ziva's face shows shock, but comprehension (same as S8 Ep 8 when Abby tells Ziva fathers do not always return)
Abby ends the hug, moves back, looks straight at Ziva. Ziva looks at her too. This time, there is some peace and calm on her face, like she has arrived at a decision. Abby leaves away from the elevator, which is surpsiginly still open and waiting for these 2.
***
Next shot:
The final shot is near the Potomac river. The tidal basin path or any other - there is a riverfront on the right, and a walkway on the left. Tony and Ziva are just walking. They keep walking, fingers sometimes touching, usually not. They don't look at each other much. Couple of times, Ziva sees something interesting - a child, something on the river, and turns to Tony. Every single time, Tony looks at her in that exact moment. There is a brief eye contact, but no conversation. Ziva appears at peace. Not happy, smiling, or anything. Just at peace. Like she has never lookedin the series so far.
They reach the base of a statue and Ziva sits down. Tony sits to her right, shoulders touching, but same step, so no one is higher or lower. No one says anything. We can hears cicadas or crickets subliminally. The background score (less obvious than crickets is Yanni's Felista)
Ziva casually puts her arm in Tony's. Tony looks startled. Then he looks at her. She is looking straight at him. But her face radiates peace. Not smile. Not happiness. Peace.
Tony: Just to be sure, I'm it? (reference to the tag game- You're it)
Ziva smiles, nods, and then leans in to kiss Tony lightly on the lips.
She makes that peck on the lips and withdraws.
Tony leans in and kisses her, deeply this time.
The cicadas stop in the background. Yanni's felitsa takes over as the main sound.
************
And now, I have the closure I need, even if it is in the head!
So, I spent a morning reading some Tony and Ziva fan fic.
Here are some that I liked:
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/8426594/1/Acknowledgement
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5399323/1/Answer_to_an_Unasked_Question
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/7008762/1/For-Better-Or-For-Worse
This book was published in 1989, so doubt its still in print. There is no listed publisher so very likely, it was self published by the poet - Guldeep Kaur Dheer, who writes as "Gul". I just found out that she retired as HoD at Chandigarh, and spoke at the Litfest in 2025!
The cover is intriguing - simple blue and white image.
The writing is good in places. In keeping with the norm of the times, focus is on using literary words.
But the spirit of the poet, thankfully, does not bow to the laws of the poem world all the time.
Some favorite pieces from the book:
लाके अपना वजूद इस जहां में
बना दिया खुदा को, तूने कर्ज़दार
This is my most favorite sher in the whole book. Some other pieces are lovely too. I will post them shortly.
कुछ टूट गया है, फिर भी बंधा है कुछ
किस अदा से तूने रिश्ते कि डोर तोड़ी है
अब अकेले हैं, शशोपंज दोराहे का लिए
कौन से मोड़ पे तूने ये डगर मोड़ी है
*******
मसरूफ़ हैं मसर्रत में, ज़रा ठहरो,
जन्नत बन रही है खलवत में, ज़रा ठहरो!
******
मुद्दतों मुंतज़िर रहे, इस सवाल के, जो तू पूछे,
"क्या मेरे बिन, इतने दिन, तू इतनी उदास रही?"
*****
गुलों, सितारों तक को राज़दां बनाया तुमने
इस लंबी फेहरिस्त में, मेरा ही नाम नहीं
****
"सिवा तेरे" - अच्छी लगी।
* *
मौजों में देखते थे, अपने ख्वाबों की ताबीर
संग डाल के मिटा दी तूने, प्यार की तस्वीर
**
न मेरे कदम तेरे डर पे रुकते हैं
न तेरे लबों से 'ठहरो' की सदा आती है
बिना बादबां के ज़ीस्त की कश्ती
चल पड़ती है जिधर से भी मौज आती है
नहीं नहीं अपनी बेबस नज़रों से हमें न देख
मेरे हाथों की लकीरों को खुद पे हया आती है
*********
खेल खेल में शुरू हुई थी जो बात
रुकते रुकते अफ़साने तलक आ पहुंची
मेरे दर्द, मेरी सिसकियों कि आवाज़,
बेवजह तेरे आशियाने तलक आ पहुंची
फिर किसी ने बेइरादा छेड़ दिया साज़
फिर मेरी ग़ज़ल वीराने तलक जा पहुंची
शमा ने तो सरापा खुद को लगाई चिंगारी
इसकी तपश कैसे ज़माने तलक जा पहुंची
********
This is not really therapy zone, but one thing abt C-PTSD is sooo true. The hard part is not living thru the tough times. That happens. the hard part begins after you are safe. Thats whent he memories attack you - in no particular order, with no warning. You are safe. After years of lack of safety, you know how grateful you should be for that safety. But you are not grateful. You are fearful. And you don't understand why.
So, after much resistance and nearly a year of therapy, I have had the courage to write abt what C PTSD is doing to the head.
If this is triggering for you, please do skip these posts. Thank you, for coming back to the blog. I really am grateful for everyone who still visits.
***********
At first, you will count the days since you last spoke
Slowly, the days will melt into each other.
The grief will either solidify into lead or wax.
If it becomes lead, it will poison you slowly.
If it becomes wax, it will melt at each heartwarming thing, and burn you just a little bit.
************
Dear Gen Z
I'm exhausted. Let's just pass the baton of the world to you and retire. Dealing with you is mentally, emotionally, and physically exhausting.
You are, at the very least, united in religion - Individualism. "Mental Health" and "Protecting my peace" are the mool mantras of your religion. Ayn Rand would be proud. The rest of us are just perplexed.
Being inconsiderate is a flex!
Even though Gen AI came out in November 2022 (that's just 4 years ago), you are incapable of writing an email without it. Your grammar is creative, punctuation misses the point, and the less said about your ability to structure an email, the better.
You are a generation that grew up on respawning video games and Ctrl Z. The concept of finality, consequences, etc., is alien to you. You also do not need to get anything right the first time because "So what? it can always be done again." We grew up without Ctrl Z. We learnt to get it right the first time. We captured the world through 36 exposure reels, not 1000 shots on an iphone and filters to boot. We do not understand the concept of doing 10 times what can be done right the first time.
Working with you is like living a nightmare. You do not understand the concept of keeping stakeholders informed. You mess up first and consult later. Your PTO is your not-negotiable birthright. Your KPIs, on the other hand, are completely optional.
You are constantly asking what everyone else brings to the table. In all these years, I have only seen u bring Zomato or Blinkit deliveries to the table.
You have SO MANY ideas. So much entitlement that everyone needs to hear your ideas out. Why? Why do we need to listen to half-baked ideas? Learn to refine them, find a presentation layer that is not claude generated, then bring them to everyone else.
You may not be able to think through a scenario fully, but that has never stopped you from interrupting whoever is trying.
We want to put you in Sales, but you cannot make a pitch.
We would put you in Coding, but you cannot do it without Claude.
We would put you in Law, but you cannot write a brief.
We would put you in Hospitality, but the hours would kill your mojo.
We would put you in administration, but balancing 3 things together is too much stress.
We could put you in teaching, but for that you would have to know something first.
And finally, dear Gen Z, here is what Gen X would like to say:
To betray you must first belong.
To desire you must first deserve.
And even in the dictionary, Responsibilities come before Rights.
Please, please, take my responsibilities. Deliver the work. Let us retire and rest. The workplace should not be a battleground of the generations. The future belongs to you. No reason the present also should not.
Best,
A tired Gen Xer.
Why its really, really hard to interact with you:
You have NO IDEA what Please means. You have never said sorry in life. You do not apologise because in your eyes, you are never wrong.
When we were in a relationship, it was an exclusive commitment, usually leading to marriage. Sure, we had flings that did not lead to marriage. We did not have a buffet of situationship, FWB, FB, polyamory......it feels like everyone has such a spread of choices now but no one is feeling satiated.
When we had to break up, we broke up. When we had to fight, we fought. We did not ghost, gaslight, breadcrumb, love bomb, bench, etc. The inability to say "I don't think this is working out" or "I think we need to talk" - WHY are you incapable of saying these sentences?
बड़े हैरान हो जी मेरी चालाकियों से
ये सब चालाकियाँ तुम ही से सीखी हैं।
डोली से उतरी थी सादा दिल गुड्डी
सभी मक्कारियाँ तुम ही से सीखी हैं
तुम्हीं ने चुप रहना सिखाया है,
और अय्यारियां तुम ही से सीखी हैं
Dear Canva
My Teams Pro subscription expired primarily because I just wasn't using you enough.
You discontinued the Teams package altogether and upped the cost to 5x for the same work. Not bad.
There is no customer support to talk to. So, no, not gonna sign up.
The desktop app is a very nice touch. Not needed, but nice touch.
The way you deleted all my content, however, is another story.
The difference between having a human to talk to and not having a human to talk to - is the subscription revenue of folks who don't really need your service, but take it all the same. And customers who wanted to talk to someone before moving to competition (which, by the way, is free).
Regards
Currently-Disgruntled-Ex-Customer
PS: You removed features that my Microsoft Powerpoint provides as default? Wow! I now understand the Canva layoffs.
सुनो, जान!
तुम झूठ मत बोला करो -
एक तो तुम प्यारे नहीं लगते
और दूसरा
तुम पकड़े जाते हो।
कहानी या कविता, लेखक/कवि के बच्चे जैसी होती है। किसी के बच्चे की आलोचना करना अच्छा नहीं लगता। अधिकाधिक हम यह कह देते हैं कि हमारे type की किताब नहीं थी।
कभी यूं भी होता है कि किसी लेखक के नकारात्मक विचार हमारे विचारों से मेल नहीं खाते परंतु हम उन्हें उस लेखक का यथार्थ समझ सकते हैं।
यह पुस्तक समीक्षा उन दोनों वर्गों में नहीं आती।
********
कहानी के कुछ अनिवार्य तत्व होते हैं - एक नायक, एक खलनायक, कुछ घटनाएँ, अंत में, सभी सिरों को जोड़ता हुआ एक समाधान।
इस पुस्तक की कहानियों में केवल खलनायक हैं। लोग या तो बुरे हैं या बेचारे।
चलिए ठीक, नायक, खलनायक न सही। तो कहानी में रह जाती है - घटनाक्रम की रोचकता, भाषा की सुंदरता...
घटनाक्रम कभी जाम में फांसी गाड़ी की गति से बढ़ता है, कभी लूनी नदी की तरह घुमावदार, किन्तु अंत में रेगिस्तान में ही विलीन होता है - किसी गंतव्य तक नहीं पहुंचता। यह कहा जा सकता है कि रेगिस्तान ही लूनी का गंतव्य है। यह तर्क की दृष्टि से ठीक है, पाठक के अनुभव के लिए सर्वथा निरर्थक।
रही भाषा की रोचकता, वह यहाँ नहीं है। यदि कुछ रूपक आदि हैं भी तो पुराने।
इन कहानियों में पढ़ने जैसा कुछ भी नहीं है। न भाषा, न पात्र, न घटनाक्रम। है तो केवल सबके लिए उगले जाने वाला विष।
***************
कुछ रचनाएँ बच्चे नहीं होतीं, ना ही किसी का अनुभव/यथार्थ होती हैं। वे बस विष के बीज होती हैं। ये कहानियाँ उस तीसरी श्रेणी की हैं।
When I left my mother's house, it meant that my parents had no day to day interference in my marital life. It also meant that i was free to visit my parents whenever i wanted, have mom-daughter dates, sis-bro time, daughter dad activities.
It also meant that my husband never asked me - "So, what did you discuss at home?" That was my prerogative. He also never asked about what was happening in my house. I never told him.
Here is how it looks when u flip the script:
His parents have zero say in how you two run your house. His parents can only come visit if BOTH of you accept that they should come. OR if both of you have a policy of anyone-can-invite-guests-over. No concept of "bete ka ghar"
He is free to visit his parents whenever he wants. He can have mom-son chats, sibling or cousin time, and dad-son dates, shared internal jokes that only they get, to which you are not privy. You are not "joining a family". You are "creating a new family with your husband." You and your husband are both parts of two families - the birth family and the marital family.
You do not ask him what he talks at home, you have no idea what is going on with the rest of the family. What he discusses with them is his business.
*******
Both of us prioritise the time we spend on our careers, and expect the relationship to flourish (or make do) with whatever time is left after our work, long hours, etc. Now, leisure/weekend belongs to both of us equally. If one chooses to go out with friends on that weekend, or sleep in, that is their right.
What I find is that some partners tend to blame their partner for "not spending time with them" or "not investing in the relationship" if they prioritise other activities. That is not fair. Stress hits everyone differently and 48 hours of stress busting is personal time. It is not fair for one to bully the other.
*****
Mother in law rules
As a boy's mother, i expect to have no relationship with his wife. I do not expect her to extend me anything more than courtesy, just as I plan to extend nothing more than that. The prerogative of initiating a deeper reln is yours, the privilege of accepting, is mine.
They are not welcome to my assets, home, or labour at their convenience. My son is always welcome, bcs i gave birth to him. I did not give birth to his partner. i am not responsible for her. When she is in my house, she is treated as a valued guest. She will conduct herself as one conducts oneself with a house host.
I do not want a daughter. You are not my daughter. You are my son's partner. He is the intersection between two family units, just as you are the intersection between two family units - your birth family and your husband.
Do we meet on family occasions? Will you be invited to larger family gatherings or weddings? Will you be expected to behave in a certain way there? I am not sure. A lot depends on your comfort. If you are not comfortable doing the trad, my son can come alone.
I do not expect you to learn or further "family traditions". You do you.
It is every couple's right to have the wedding ceremony of their choice. So, at the wedding, my son will get a lumpsum amount from me. He can choose to do anything with it - buy wife jewelry, make a downpayment on a house, conduct a destination wedding... their call. What we will not do is spend money, time and effort to make your dream of a wedding real. You want a 3 lakh Tarun Tahiliani lehnga? By all means. You want a white and purple orchid theme for pheras? Of course! Pay for it, arrange for it, break your head with the florist. Good luck!
Accept the fact that his father and I are separated. You do not get to comment on that separation, just as we don't get to comment on your relationship with your husband.
Irrespective of what Gibran says, your children ARE your children. No free babysitting.
If you are dieting or have special food needs, pls carry your food and help yourself when we are all meeting. No pressure to eat what everyone else is eating, no snide remarks, nothing.
You are almost guaranteed to have a better reln with your fil than with your husband or me. Please refrain from telling us what a wonderful human being he is. Trust me, we KNOW. We are backstage, you are in the audience. We're not the same.
My son and I should ideally continue to have mom-son dates without you. At least once a month. There was a reln that lasted his whole life. Now, it must change, but it cannot disappear.
Pls know that i WILL support my son like a rock if the reln turns abusive. And if i suspect that he is the source of abuse, I will reach out to you and talk, irrespective of our non-existent reln.
What you wear, who you meet, how you manage your career and finances, is between the two of you. How you treat us if we ever visit, that's on you.
Just like I will not tell my son slimy things about you behind your back, you will not do "your mom" complaints behind my back. You have an issue? Talk to me. I have an issue? I will talk to you. Usually, its just communication gaps which become bigger when we go via someone.
If ANYONE in the family is mean to you, or is perceived as mean by you, pls respond to them as you would respond to someone in your own family/extended circle. You are under no obligation to maintain a relationship with them. Relationship building works both ways. If they are offended and bring it up with me, I will handle it.
Only one of these 2 headlines is correct. In case there was any confusion, it is the second one. The PM of India got Xi Jinping to India, and then raised to his face, the issue of weaponising rare earth minerals.
I don't think people have quite understand the magnitude of what happened at the BRICS Summit, so let me lay it out a little bit.
1. Xi Jinping and Putin are two global leaders who are on the target list of every terror orgn and state led assassination agencies (except, perhaps, N Korea). These leaders do not "tour". Their security is a 24*7*365 race.
India managed to bring these and other global leaders on a single stage, managed their security, without any incident. If RAW needed a coming of age certificate, this is IT.
2. These leaders also do not issue statements. They do not share their thoughts. Ever. They are intensely private and very action oriented.
These leaders came to a central platform and issued a JOINT, consensual statement with India, Iran, and other countries. These countries do not always see eye to eye on the global stage. India did this under clear and present threat of US Sanctions. Getting these leaders to SPEAK, and issue a joint statement, is not something that is easily achieved.
Putin, as usual, slayed in one sentence - BRICS is 40% of the world's GDP, G7 is 29%. Why do they call themselves "great".
3. The issue is not the use of the term G7 or % of GDP being the only metric for a country's economy. The issue is - the world has been benefitting purely from spotlight for a long time. When you remove the greasepaint, the substance beneath the paint has to be good. And more people are asking - Is it?
Is as much as the spotlight is on BRICS and who is in the room, it is also, imho, on the people who were NOT in that room.
Completely off-topic:
As a random person, this week, my thoughts took me to a very different tangent - many great economies have been undone by democracy, but none as much as the UK. Yet, in ancient India, democracy was the norm. The janapadas were the first known political system. As the size and complexity grew, they had to move to monarchies and central control with ONE person. There were checks and balances - the Rajguru whose curse scared even the king, the group of ministers who exuded the same pressure that Gandhi exuded on the British.
What, then, is the future of democracies like India and the US? These are great countries. And democracy is easily the best political system for the people. So, why do these two not lead to synergy? In Switzerland, by contrast, direct democracy has led to a country that is efficient, well-regulated, and extremely rich. What did Switzerland do so right that the rest of the world can learn from? How can we make democracy relevant, and also powerful?
You read the AI generated summary of a research paper and then share it, expound on it, and use it to base an argument.
I read the first 5 paragraphs of the paper and realise that:
A. The Sample is inadequate (2676 people representing 1.4 bn)
B. The sample is also incredibly skewed (one population group comprising 75% of population while paper claiming to represent the entire universal set of study)
C. The stratification employed is irrelevant.
We are not the same.
PS:
1. If you use a paper to base an entire argument, at least read the damn paper. When I call you out on it, don't say - eyes hurt, can't read more at the moment.
2. Do NOT come to me with AI generated content. We can ALL tell AI content from the first 2 paragraphs. If i wanted to know what AI thinks, I would ask the AI.
तुम्हारे बारे में पूछते होंगे
वो सब लोग जिन से हंस कर मिला करती थीं तुम।
वो कुछ लोग
जो तुमसे मिल कर हंस दिया करते थे
वो तुम्हारे बारे में
अब पूछ नहीं सकते।
कहाँ गई थीं?
कुछ
सामान खरीदना था, तो आशीष साथ में चल पड़ा था।
हम्म।
अच्छा, तो मैं चलता हूँ।
अरे?
अचानक?
चाय
पिलाने के लिए रवि, समान खरीदवाने के लिए आशीष, बातें सुनने के लिए राहुल। मेरे हर
रोल में कोई न कोई नाम भर गया है। अब मेरी क्या जगह है यहाँ?
तुम्हारा
एक ही रोल था हमेशा से – तुम। और उस रोल को कोई नहीं भर पाएगा।
This is the second part. The first part of the post is here.
So, in doing some fieldwork, I have noticed a few things that ARE common to families that either remain in poverty, or enter poverty from a more affluent class.
This is the TOP common denominator. EVERYONE who remains in poverty has expressed deep anguish at being wronged - the agent of wrongdoing varies - the state, the community, the world, the family. But they are ALL victims. They have been wronged by the world.
BUT not everyone who has a victim mindset remains poor. There is one more factor which has to be added to the mix - they truly believe that the wrong must be recompensed before they can do anything. I call this the victimhood paralysis - they find that they are unable/unwilling to act until the wrong done to them has been "corrected" or they have been somehow compensated.
The second common factor is - they feel entitled to abuse - public infrastructure, other people. I stop people who are spitting and ask them - Why did you spit here?
Some of them express surface level remorse. Only a few stop to really think. Most of them look at me like i am an alien. To them, defacing public property is the most natural thing to do. Their answer is the same as Hillary's answer to "Why climb a mountain?" - Because it is there!
And then I notice that in my most underprivileged contacts, the same mindset extends to people. They do not feel bad about abusing their network for short term gain, then wonder why they have "no friends" and why "no one supports them"
Maybe there are more factors. But this is what I know so far. Every time I meet someone underprivileged, I ask "Why is this family poor?" (Because poverty is not an individual phenomenon. One is not poor alone. The lowest unit of poverty is the family. If one person gets out of poverty, they may get out alone. But if one person in the family becomes poor, the whole immediate family definitely follows suit.)
The exodus is rarely quick or en masse. Some people leave first - the ones who can see the shape of things to come. They make arrangements quietly, perhaps move the family first, and then move - lock, stock, and barrel.
Then, some perceptive relatives and friends start asking themselves the same question - is this daily hate worth it?
Then, the waves begin.
The only ones who remain are the ones who do not have a choice.
This is true of all types of exodus:
A. Before partition, when the writing was on the wall but patriotism and Congress had made us blind. (And then, in Syria, Lebanon, etc.)
B. When a country (or, in case of India, a state) runs anti-immigration campaigns
C. When a company is doing layoffs.
The conversation was not about politics. It was about why I was watching Filmfare and not National Film Awards, back in 1999.
"Both the National Film Awards and the Padma awards were such a joke back then - only for political patronage. No one even read who got these awards. We only followed Filmfare awards. Now I really want to know the work done by Padma awardees because they are real changemakers. But back then we would not even read them for quizzes."
.. And i paused.
We have gotten so used to living in an India where progress happens, that we have forgotten what India felt like before 2014. Of course, Cockroach Party reminds us once in a while, as do "public" protests. But in general, the experience of India has changed so much that its hard to remember what we lived through.
Perhaps it is time to take a minute to appreciate how far we have come, India.
I am going to get brickbats for this one.
Recently, i was at a railway station. India now has brilliant public infrastructure. The railway station was no exception.
We have to climb stairs to reach platforms. At least 5 people walking in front of me spat or littered on their way to the platform. Without a care.
And that anger led to a tsunami of processing data points that have been silently accumulated over decades.
**********
In 1947, Muslims from India reached Pakistan but instead of being welcomed, they were labelled Muhajirs.
Hindus and Sikhs who managed to reach India alive were rich in their towns and villages (you had to be rich enough to pay for safe passage and reach this side alive, that is why every Punjabi in Delhi had grandparents who spoke about being wealthy. They were), but were put here in refugee camps in squalor, food itself being a luxury doled out at infrequent intervals.
But, in 2004, the president of Pakistan was a Muhajir, and the Prime Minister of India was a refugee.
They were not exceptional - on both sides of the border, the communities of these "refugees" had done well financially.
**********
In the 1960s -1970s India, lakhs of young men and women left homes for PSU jobs, govt jobs, IIT education, IIM education. They went on to reach "escape velocity" from poverty.
*********
When we speak about poverty, we address it as a single story - poverty is a result of circumstances out of an individual's control. It is a result of the evil capitalistic/oligarchic/regal system, which rely/ies on suppressing the poor for the benefit of the rich.
Here is what is wrong with that single story:
1. There ISN'T a single story of poverty. Poverty is a multi-headed hydra. There isn't a single cause of poverty.
2. The narrative of capitalism/oligarchy/monarchy being solely responsible for poverty comes from socio-economic structures that truly did not have space for what is now called the "middle classes" - people who fill the middle role through education or specialised skill. In India, which was a mercantile civilisation from the start, trade was a good way to reach the middle class and this class has been a ubiquitous feature of our civilisation.
3. There are people who exit poverty and take their families along. There are people who exit but do not take the family along. And then there are families that stay in the same loop - generation after generation. And families that enter the loop - from one of the "upper" classes. We know what helps those who reach escape velocity - education, enterprise, opportunity, community, etc. We never ask - what, if anything, is common to families that remain poor? Why is a poor person poor?
**************
So, let's ask the question - Why is a poor person poor?
And i call this, the Poverty mindset.
More in the next post.
I am aware of my spiritual potential but not ready to live that truth.
I take baby steps and my meditation waits. :) In a really really long existence, a few decades to accept one's spiritual place is not a catastrophe. Slows down the soul, yes, but not a catastrophe. The only casualty are the ppl who know they belong in ur journey, but you don't know that yet.
Sometimes, your meditation deliberately derails you, like its having its fun with you. Maya.
1.
The currency of a relationship is not money, address, or education. It is how well two people communicate, how valued they make each other feel - communication, respect, love, passion, chemistry?
With age, the relative importance of biodata elements like money, title, education etc. reduces even more. Now all we need is someone to sit with, someone to talk to, and someone to trust/lean on.
In youth, what is important is - will this person stand up for you? Will they support or criticise you when you fail, or lose a job, or hit a wall? Will they lend a hand in the backbreaking work of raising a family while managing finances, relatives, expectations? Or will they stand on the side and guilt trip you?
Yet, we continue to evaluate potential partners on currencies that are not completely valid. Educational compatibility is a good indicator of some other things - like a non medico may not understand the idea of 36 hour shifts. But it can lead to false positives and false negatives - not all medicos will get it, and its not that only medicos will get it. They may not have lived 36 hour shifts, but they see you do them and see you come home exhausted.
2. In offices, when doing DEI trainings, we almost always present a variant of this picture:
Yet, when talking to our partners, we expect equality - I value honesty, so I must offer honesty. I value time spent together doing things, so I must offer to do things my partner enjoys, even if I dont like them that much.
But quid pro quo rarely works. Love your partner the way they want to be loved, not the way you want to love. And ask to be loved in a way that works for you.
In a relationship, equity means - the ability to love the way your partner wants, and the security to ask to be loved in the way your heart desires.
To borrow from St. Francis of Assisi:
To be understood, as to understand.
Electrons
are lighter
than protons.
And they circulate on the periphery - never
at the center of things.
Negativity can be preponderous
Not significant.
Preface: Bulle Shah wrote:
ज़हर वेख के पीता, ते की पीतावे बुल्ले्या प्यार इहो जिया कीता, ते की कीता?
AND this:
नी मैं कमली यार दी कमली
राँझा राँझा करदी नी मैं आपे राँझा होई
सद्दो नी मैनू दीदो राँझा हीर न आखो कोई
i wrote this with some reference to the lines above:
बिन सोच दा चा वे सजना
या ते बुल्ला, या कोई कमला
ते जेड़ा कर लैसी,
सो कमला थी जासी -
- न कुज खट्टे, न कुज पल्ले।
दाना बनके कमला होईं ।
ਬਿਨੁ ਸੋਚ ਦਾ ਚਾਹ ਵੇ ਸੱਜਣਾ
ਯਾ ਤੇ ਬੁੱਲ਼੍ਆ, ਯਾ ਕੋਈ ਕਮਲਾ
ਯਾ ਜੇਡਾ ਕਰ ਲਾਇਸੀ
ਸੋ ਕਮਲਾ ਧੀ ਜਾਸੀ
ਨ ਕੁਜ ਖੱਟੇ, ਨ ਕੁਜ ਪੱਲੇ।
ਦਾਣਾ ਬਣ ਕੇ ਕਮਲਾ ਹੋਈਂ।
The same thing in Hindi:
परिमाण = proportion
परिमाण में प्रेम करना
प्रेम में
परिमाण रखना
बेतहाशा चाहने से
बेहिसी ही मिलती है
In English
Love
Proportionately
Keep proportion in love
Loving like crazy
usually works out
exactly that way.
बहुत प्रेम करता हूँ तुमसे
थोड़ा सा प्रेम, तुम भी कर लो मुझ से
अगर कर सको तो।
नहीं कर पाओ तो
कोई बात नहीं
प्रेम बहता रहेगा
मुझ से तुम तक
तुम्हारी खैर की दुआओं में
तुम्हारे जन्मदिन की पूजाओं में
अंत में
Balance हो जाते हैं
सभी खाते
और कुछ नहीं तो
balance carried forward से।
पीड़ा का अपना कोई पदार्थ या भार नहीं होता।
वह जिस हाथ में होती है, उसके आधार पर उसका पदार्थ और भार निर्धारित हो जाता है।
मेरे हाथ में रखी मेरी पीड़ा युरेनीअम की होती है - बहुत, बहुत भारी, और बहुत, बहुत विरली, rare, दुनिया में सबसे अलग।
किसी मित्र के हाथ में जा कर, सोने की हो जाती है - कीमती, युरेनीअम से कम भारी, थोड़ी सी कम rare, पर अब भी असाधारण।
प्रेम के हाथ में पड़ते ही, मोती बन जाती है। वह देख पाता है, वह सारी पीड़ा, जो इस पीड़ा से भी पहले सही गई। उसके हाथों में, दुख भी सुंदर हो जाता है।
रिश्तेदारों के हाथ में अपनी पीड़ा हो जाती है ऊन की गेंद - एक बहुत आम सी, रोजमर्रा की चीज़, जिस से या तो कहानियाँ बुनी जा सकती हैं, या जिसे फरोल-फरोल कर उस से खेला जा सकता है - अगला खिलौना मिलने तक।
और किसी बेकदरे के हाथ में, पीड़ा बन जाती है कमरे के कोने की धूल - जिसे केवल अनदेखा किया जाना चाहिए। जिस पर हाथ भी नहीं फेरना चाहिए। न वज़न रह जाता है, न मोल। केवल उपेक्षा।
प्यार न, swimming pool के जैसा होता है। लगता है, इतना सा तो पानी है, वो तो रही ज़मीन।
इस में तो आराम से सीधे खड़े हो जाएंगे। गहराई कहाँ है?
फिर
हम उस में पैर रखते हैं और गोता खाने लगते
हैं। तब सच्चाई समझ में आती है। इस तरण ताल में, किसी को तैरना नहीं आता। क्यूंकि
तुम कितने भी पारंगत खिलाड़ी रहे हो, ये तरण ताल हमेशा उस से ज़्यादा गहरा निकलता है।
और इसे नियति समझने वाले?
मेरे सीने में एक खलिश सी है
सुघड़ खलिश है, अनुभवी है
न भरती है, न घटती है, न रह पाती है अनछुई
सांस दर सांस बीतते हैं हफ्ते, महीने, साल
घड़ी की टिकटिक
धीरे धीरे
हो गई है बेमानी।
ये खलिश
घर के मेधावी प्रेत सी है
जकड़ लेती है
कभी अलमारी को, जिस में
रिसाले रखे थे उन दोस्तों के
जिन्हें अब whatsapp text भी लिखने नहीं आते
कभी रसोई घर की उस कड़छी को
जिस से दाल बनाई थी
किसी खास इंसान के साथ
हर चीज़, हर कोना, हर शब्द
कुछ देर के लिए
खो देते हैं अपना मानी
और बन जाते हैं खलिश
फिर ये
कूद कर आ बैठती है
मन के भीतर - अपने कोठर में
क्यूंकि
घर से दूर
प्रेत भी नहीं रह पाते।
What an incredible book this is!
A lot of cases involving a simple case of drugging the victim - nothing more. harmless at one level. Except, a kid is kidnapped, a lady loses an important contract because she missed a flight, and a TV Producer is badly injured. Not that harmless any more.
The case meanders through the usual route of sleuthing - following leads, red herrings, missed opportunities and disappointments, until a chance encounter opens their eyes to something bizarre - and sinister.
The writing is gripping from the word Go. The stories - and there are quite a few of them - are all well woven, with no loose ends, no obvious plotholes, and a lot of substance.
The final plot is incredibly well drawn. It is a cautionary late - because it is sooo real today. No spoilers, but this is a plot that one totally needs to read. The love story slowly brewing on the side doesn't hurt. The story reads like a screenplay, and its easy to imagine events as they are unfolding. The book is not too long. Its a lovely, breezy read and is truly unputdownable - even for screen hardened folks who find it hard to concentrate, and that's saying something!
The book is divided into two parts. The first part is the author's account of life in Nazi camps - as a prisoner. The perspective, however, is very different. It does not focus on the living conditions, the torture, or the uncertainty of not knowing what is happening to one's family. It focuses on what individuals did with all of that - how they interpreted the conditions, their mental processes. The signal of smoking as a last pleasant thing before they decide to die.
The second part of the book introduces logotherapy - a system of therapy that believes that one who has a Why to live can manage any How.
Since I don't have a Why to live, i cant really identify with the premise of the book, but the book has enough cases of people who discovered their mojo once they were able to find the purpose of their lives. The author says that it may not apply to everyone, but does apply to most people, and to that extent, i do agree. People with purpose in their lives might be happier and more content.
The second part does not read like a textbook. Only an introductory primer. It is not pedantic, pontificating, or pestilent in its persistence that logotherapy is the one best kind of therapy. That is a relief. It gives the reader an opportunity to explore and mildly understand the idea, read some cases where it helped, and then leaves one to think.
The book is brief and is a good, engaging read.
This is not grief
that will settle
in a day, week, or month.
This will hit
while riding a bike
or driving a car
at random traffic signals
Tears welling up
out of nowhere
as i wait
for the signal to turn green
Wondering
whether they have
traffic lights in heaven
and why
they don't allow U turns.
*******
When a childhood friend dies, a part of our childhood dies with them. Sometimes, its a shard of glass. Sometimes, a waxx crayon. Sometimes, a shiny piece of plastic.
इस रिश्ते की सारी हदें तो तुम ही तय करती हो - ये नहीं कर सकती, ये नहीं कह सकती..
एक बार बेहद प्रेम किया था किसी से।
उसी से सीखा - अपनी हद में रहा करो।
*******
If you have been wanting to start reading Hindi, this is the perfect kind of book. It has short stories that range from half page to two pages.
But don't be fooled by the word count. Each story manages to do its job - make the reader feel, think, or both.
The book is a compilation of short stories written by Suryakant Nagar, Bhagirath, Dr. Satishraj Pushkarna, Shyamsundar Agrawal, Dr. Ramnivas 'Maanav', Dr. Kamal Chopra, and Sukesh Sahni.
11 stories of each author have been selected, making this a compendium of 77 stories in a very compact 134 pages.
The language is easy and the writing flows. You wont experience it as a compilation because there is no jarring difference between the styles of individual authors. One doesn't get the sense of reading Christie and Thomas Hardy in the same book. And for that, the editor, Dr. Ramkumar Ghotad, deserves credit.
The stories span pretty much the entire spectrum of human conditions and emotions. From love in an elderly couple to crime in a village, it is all there.
The book is not available in print, afaik.
Friends can borrow my copy though, or you could try the publishers - Sahityagaar (Jaipur).